fbpx

We Deserve Better Than Hasan Minhaj’s Baity, Awkward Coverage of the NRC‑CAA

By

Dec 23, 2019

Share

The Patriot Act with Hasan Minhaj
Image Credits : Netflix

On Saturday, comedian Hasan Minhaj dropped a minute-long promo of the next episode of his well-loved show, Patriot Act with Hasan Minhaj. The trailer promised “#CAA + #NRC + more this Sunday on @patriotact,” which led to significant positive responses and anticipation from the Indian community, mainly due to both Minhaj’s objective, honest rendering of political events on Netflix, an international streaming platform, and lackluster or biased news coverage by Indian media.

The timing couldn’t be better — both the CAA and the NRC are grossly discriminative, bigoted legislative actions centered around the disenfranchisement and exclusion of Muslim citizens and refugees, women, Dalits, tribals and trans persons. The recent passing of the CAA bill elicited scores of protests from Indian citizens, leading to violent police backlash. While the National Register of Citizens requires Assam’s (and in the future possibly all of India’s) residents to prove their presence in India on or before March 24, 1971, the Citizenship (Amendment) Act intends to offer Indian citizenship to migrants belonging to minority religious groups in Afghanistan, Pakistan, and Bangladesh, except Islam since these three countries are Islamic states. This effectively means people who fail to provide documentation for the NRC will become ‘doubtful citizens’ who can then apply for Indian citizenship through the CAA — except Muslims.

Now, Minhaj, with his Indian and Islamic roots, intelligent commentary and global goodwill, could have been key to spreading greater and international awareness of the horror unfolding in the country, if only he hadn’t completely fudged his attempt to do so. The latest episode of Patriot Act dropped on Sunday, as expected, but with the title “How America Is Causing Global Obesity.” Confusion ensured; didn’t Minhaj specifically drop a trailer that promised an episode centered around the CAA + NRC issues? Conspiracy theories about government cover-ups were floated on social media, but the truth was far from glamorous.


Related on The Swaddle:

Why We Are Able to Empathize With Some, Never All


Towards the end of the episode, Minhaj decides to take us through 2019 and its comedy show of horrors, of which a minute and thirteen seconds are dedicated to India — covering Kashmir’s internet black-out, the NRC and the CAA. This was also exactly the content he had already uploaded to his IGTV as a promotional video. Basically, we’ve been had. We were clickbaited into believing Minhaj would drop an entire dedicated episode centered around one of the most significant developments in India’s volatile socio-political history, and then, we were delivered a minute and thirteen seconds tucked away at the tail-end of an episode on obesity, where nobody would find it.

This carelessness is particularly irritating, because Minhaj is no stranger to talking extensively about politics or India, and is currently one of the most famous faces of the Indian diaspora. He wears his family’s Aligarh origins on his sleeve in his first-ever stand-up special, Hasan Minhaj: Homecoming King. In season one of the Patriot Act, he covers Jamal Khashoggi’s murder, which was later pulled down in Saudi Arabia by Netflix due to the feathers it ruffled. He even covers the Indian elections in season two, notably (painfully) calling Lok Sabha Member of Parliament Shashi Tharoor “thicc” within the segment. His fame and his credibility lent to issues like the CAA and the NRC would have helped both Indian audiences receive an unbiased, well-researched and relatable take on the issue and would have let a global audience access the issue, leading to global condemnation for large-scale human rights violations across India.

Yet, Kashmir’s internet blackout, the NRC and the CAA inspire nothing but a minute of milquetoast jokes about how the Kashmiris are missing out on Karachi-born Kumail Nanjiani’s new post-workout body, and how the Prime Minister Narendra Modi is like a nightclub bouncer keeping Muslim refugees out of India. Minhaj’s hinting at an entire upcoming episode on social media and driving up hype when NRC and CAA were trending on social media, followed by delivering the most paltry of commentaries as an afterthought in an episode about something else entirely is a tacky, irresponsible way to catch more eyeballs off a sensitive, pressing topic. Charming.

It is worth a watch, of course, but only if you care about America’s growing obesity epidemic. I’d say read the news instead, but considering recent coverage, that’s no help either.

Share

Written By Aditi Murti

Aditi Murti is the senior culture writer at The Swaddle, with an interest in cultural analysis, environment, and the science of mental health.  Write to her using aditi@theswaddle.com, or find her on social media @aditimurti.

  1. Asiya

    I was dissappointed too but you’ll have to consider the timeline and maybe even lack of context the Patriot Act team would have while filming this episode. Maybe while they were filming this, the protests were just starting or it may have been right before the JMI incident. I’m only giving him the benefit of the doubt because of how extensively the Kashmir episode was covered.

    But yes, the news definitely has a more updated coverage of what’s happening right now than that episode would ever have been able to provide.

  2. Kritin Bansal

    First of all, when you say that the CAA is discriminatory, you are disrespecting and ignoring the Indian constitution and the supreme court of india. As per article 14 of the constitution, and the supreme court has said this, there can be positive discrimination on the grounds of reasonable classification (ortherwise the reservation in India for the backward and the poor would be wrong). Second of all, when people talk about the NRC they talk about the Assam NRC which is governed by the Assam accord signed in the late 1900s.
    Also the NRC which will be conducted on a nationwide basis will be under the citizenship act under a different clause.
    Moreover, if you talk about Assam and how CAA will be discriminatory over there, that makes sense except the fact that there has been an “east line”, created under the CAA which specifies that CAA will not be implemented in whole in Assam, tripura, Mizoram and Manipur.
    Being a respected media frontier, i reguest to research the topics with an open mind before letting biases creep in

  3. Kshitij

    He is not running a news channel show
    Every episode topic he pick is pre-plan and it got a lots of research material. In this short period of time and research they did very well to put some light on the situation going in India. I think they will do a full episode on CAA , NCR or talk about it in their DEEP CUTS on youtube.

  4. Saurabh Joshi

    I would suggest you check the details correctly about CAB before publishing your views. The bill has been passed in both houses, by our own elected representatives.

  5. A.T.

    There is no exclusion of “women, Dalits, tribals and trans persons.” This is misleading information. Please do proper research. False information incites violent protests in India, something we’re not proud of. Even the part about Muslims is debatable, but this is not the right platform.

Share

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields *.

The latest in health, gender & culture in India -- and why it matters. Delivered to your inbox weekly.